FGM/C Shifting Sands

Language Articles

Interview with Zainab Nur "Revictimization of Affected Women by the Anti-FGM Campaign"

Zainab Nur: ‘Revictimization of Affected Women by the Anti-FGM Campaign’

Published 4 January 2025

The 2023 World Association of Sexual Health Conference was held in Antalya, Turkey, 2-5 November 2023.

Bridging the gaps in Sexual Health, Rights, Justice and Pleasure in Africa: The imperative for eradication of FGM was a plenary session (P15) and the promotional material for it follows.

“Uwem Esiet

The global quest for ensuring sexual health, rights, justice and pleasure is most laudable and very desirable. However, each continent has peculiar challenges thus there is the need to galvanize efforts and initiatives

to respond to specific continental challenges. One of the most devastating socio-cultural practices that impedes and violates sexual health, rights, justice and pleasure is the heinous practice of Female Genital Mutilation (FGM). Africa is home to over 1.4 billion persons of many diverse ethno-cultural backgrounds, but regrettably the continent has the highest number of countries where FGM is practiced.

An estimated 55 million girls under the age of 15 in 28 African countries have experienced or are at risk of experiencing FGM thus accounting for about 80% of all FGM cases worldwide. The countries include:

Benin, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Chad, Cote D’Ivoire, Dijbouti, Egypt

Eritrea, Ethiopia, Gambia, Ghana, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Kenya, Liberia, Mali, Mauritania, Niger

Nigeria, Senegal, Sierra Leone, Somalia, Sudan, Tanzania, Togo, Uganda.

The risk of FGM practice has also become a major ground for seeking Asylum. Despite the fact that eradicating FGM has been a major SRHR agenda of the African Union Commission since 2006 as stated in the Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights Continental Policy Framework, this has remained a mirage. Thus, to guarantee sexual health, rights, justice and pleasure in Africa, new innovative approaches at eradicating FGM become imperative.”

This interview with Zainab Nur of the Cardiff Somali community and Hidden Voices UK was recorded for the event and published in November 2023. 

The interviewer is Brian Earp. He was then Senior Research Fellow, University of Oxford.  He is now Associate Professor and Director, Oxford-NUS Centre for Neuroethics & Society, University of Oxford and National University of Singapore.

He introduces Zainab Nur as “one of the first campaigners against female genital cutting in the UK, who now argues that the movement has become an “industry” that ultimately harms affected communities, women, and girls.” 

Aspects covered in the 27 minute discussion include Genital autonomy (1.07), Early activism (2.43), Power dynamics (4.21 ), Consent vs harm (6.10), Misconceptions (8.40), FGM (11.10), Successful prosecution (15.03) and Labiaplasty (16.58).

 


Is trans surgery just state-sanctioned mutilation?

Is trans surgery just state-sanctioned mutilation?

Published 27 June 2022

Brendan O’Neill spiked’s chief political writer recently published this insightful piece.

Read More

Am I a victim?

Am I a victim?: My experience with female circumcision

Published 17 December 2020

This poem, by Malaysian born Idura Hisham, concluded a blog written by her,

Read More

FGM awareness-raising

APPG on PDRH

Contributions to APPG on PDRH – FGM

Published 9 March 2020

The year’s first APPG on PDRH (All-Party Parliamentary Group on Population, Development and Reproductive Health)

Read More

The moral licensing of FGM actors

The moral licensing of FGM actors

Published 18 July 2019

I’ve recently come across the term ‘moral licensing’ and think it usefully explains how and why actors in the FGM industry behave as they do.

Read More

Is trans surgery just state-sanctioned mutilation?

Aus trial not Mutilation

Verdict: Female circumcision is not mutilation

Published 24 September 2018

In Australia, in 2015, three Dawoodi Bohras (a small Shia Muslim sect) were convicted

Read More

Medicine, Morals, and Female Genital Cutting

Medicine, Morals, and Female Genital Cutting

Published 23 January 2018

The arrest of Jumana Nagarwala and her colleagues,

Read More

Dawoodi Bohra and FGC

‘FGM’: Reflecting on the language we use

Published 23 January 2018

The word ‘mutilation’ turns any question on female genital procedures

Read More